Trend

Why body honesty could be the next step for the body positivity movement

Southpaw’s Niki Macartney examines a shifting body positivity ideal, exploring both our physical health and mental wellbeing. Does what’s happening on the inside count for anything in 2020?

Niki Macartney

Strategy Director Southpaw

Share


In 2019 Victoria’s Secret hit the headlines for cancelling their annual show and embarking on a collaboration fronted by a plus size model. For a brand built on size zero fantasy and fronted by identikit Angels, this was quite the volte-face. So, what’s changed?

Demand for inclusivity, that’s what. The need to see bodies in shapes and sizes that we can identify with. The body positivity movement is seemingly in its absolute element and we have brands and ‘influencers’ in large part to thank for this. Aspiration isn’t dead but wing-wearing, hard-bodied living dolls just might be. 

But hang on: we’re still scrutinising semi-naked bodies. The gaze has never been so intense. And what’s more the conversation is still geared towards how we look and then, how we feel about how we look. 

What about our physical health and mental wellbeing? Does what’s happening on the inside count for anything in 2020? 

Recognise the individual’s right to choose how they feel on any given day about their looks and their health and be the brand that champions that.

Niki Macartney

A shifting body positivity ideal

The roots of body positivity originated from the culturally and politically subversive fat-acceptance movement of the Sixties. But the moment that ignited the modern-day body positive crusade came when brands commercialised the message and used it to shake up the beauty industry. There is none more famous than Dove’s ‘Real Beauty’ campaign, launched in 2004. Radical at the time, it challenged and deconstructed the trickery used by the category to promote narrow standards of beauty for profit. 

Nowadays Instagram is full of, still gorgeous, models and ‘influencers’ publishing their back fat and cellulite, while brands tick diversity boxes with plus size casting and pare back Photoshop manipulation. It’s not just women either; men are equally confronted with intimidating examples of fit physiques in the prime of life.  

Body positivity is well intentioned but in darker moments can put us under pressure, delivering a dishonest and daunting message. And hey, we give a shit about what’s happening on the inside, too! 

Body honesty

We believe there’s a better space for brands and influencers to inhabit and we’re calling it ‘body honesty’. Let’s embrace the notion that it’s ok to feel ‘just ok’, both mentally and physically. 

Well done to Virgin Active, who shot out of the blocks this time last year with their advertising campaign ‘Enough’. It was designed to communicate a realistic message about exercising and new year resolutions, rather than the usual ‘all or nothing’ guilt-fest. But it’s the food and beverage sector that has the opportunity to lead real change.

Ultimately, ‘body honesty’ is about sending a message of freedom, one that liberates consumers from the pressures of the past. Recognise the individual’s right to choose how they feel on any given day about their looks and their health and be the brand that champions that. That’s where the future lies.

Guest Author

Niki Macartney

Strategy Director Southpaw

About

Niki is a Creative Strategist with 25 years’ experience in strategy development, comms planning, brand management and market research, across national and global business. Working with global clients across a wide range of categories, such as Diageo, Honda, Molsen Coors, Eurotunnel, ghd, Octopus and PZ Cussons.