Loading...
Loading...
Voices

Football is the last place older men talk about mental health, but the first place they’ll listen

Carol McNicol shares how looking to football can help tackle mental health taboos.

Carol McNicol

Account Director Leith

Share


Football has a reputation for being slow to act on social issues. It is often described as tribal, defensive, resistant to change and more comfortable reacting to problems than addressing them. It is not the place most people would expect to see meaningful progress on something as sensitive as mental health, especially for older men who are often the hardest group to reach.

Yet football is also one of the few environments where older men express emotion freely. They shout, they feel, they care, they let things out without hesitation. It is a space where emotion is normalised and shared, even if it is rarely directed toward their own well-being. That contradiction creates an unexpected opportunity. Football may not look like a natural home for mental health support, but it is one of the only places where older men are already emotionally open and socially present.

Older men are a difficult audience for mental health communication. Many grew up in a culture where emotional restraint was expected and where asking for help carried a sense of personal weakness. They do not seek out wellbeing content, they do not identify with the language of mental health, and they do not trust institutions to speak to them in a way that feels relevant. They are not hostile to support, but they are uncomfortable with the idea of being seen to need it.

Football is also one of the few environments where older men express emotion freely.

Carol McNicol, Account Director, Leith

This is why traditional campaigns struggle. You cannot rely on digital targeting because they are not searching for this content. You cannot rely on institutional authority because they do not trust it. You cannot rely on self‑initiated help seeking because it rarely happens until crisis point. If you want to reach older men, you have to meet them in the places where they already feel comfortable, not the places where you wish they would feel comfortable.

That is what has been happening in Scotland, where the Scottish Government’s Mind to Mind campaign has taken mental health support into football culture itself. Instead of asking older men to come to the message, the message goes to them. And crucially, it does so through the voices and institutions they trust most.

Clubs across the entire football pyramid have taken part. Spartans show the power of community football. Falkirk and Motherwell bring strong regional and working-class identities. Hibs and Hearts represent two of the biggest clubs in the capital. Rangers brings national scale and reach. The breadth of involvement matters because it shows that mental health support can sit inside football culture at every level, not just elite clubs with large media teams.

What makes this work is not spectacle. It is familiarity. The campaign appears in the places older men already look. Matchday screens. LED boards. Programmes. Newsletters. Podcasts. Hospitality suites. Club websites. Player ambassador films. Posters in toilets. Leaflets in club shops. Nothing feels out of place. Nothing feels like an intervention. It is simply part of the environment.

Players also play a crucial role. Older men may not listen to a government, but they will listen to a player who represents their club. A player saying it is normal to struggle carries a different weight. It gives permission. It makes the message feel like it belongs inside football, not outside it.

What this reveals is something important about male behaviour. Older men do not necessarily reject help, but they do rebel against the feeling of being singled out. Football solves that problem. It is both collective and anonymous. A message delivered in a stadium does not feel like it is aimed at you; it feels like it is aimed at everyone. That makes it easier to absorb and harder to dismiss.

The model is simple but powerful. Take mental health support into the places where older men already feel. Use the voices they trust. Make the message part of the environment rather than a disruption to it. Repeat it often enough that it becomes familiar rather than confronting.

This is not just a Scottish story. It is a blueprint for any country where football is culture, identity and community. The details will change, but the principle holds. If you want to reach older men with a subject they are uncomfortable with, you have to understand the emotional logic of their world, not the emotional logic of yours.

Older men may not talk about their mental health in the stands. But they listen. And sometimes, listening is the first step toward talking.

Guest Author

Carol McNicol

Account Director Leith

About

Carol is a seasoned Account Director with a talent for delivering high-impact brand experiences and integrated campaigns. With over 20 years of expertise, she has navigated complex sectors ranging from financial services to public health. Carol was a cornerstone of the COP26 campaign delivery and brings extensive experience to the Scottish Government, where she has led numerous Health and Road Safety initiatives. Her background in internal communications for major financial institutions ensures a 360-degree approach to every project she touches.

Agencies Featured